• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Jared Dees

Author. Speaker. Teacher.

  • About
    • Now
    • Projects
    • Speaking
    • Contact
  • Books
    • Beatitales
    • Tales of the Ten Commandments
    • Take and Eat
    • Do Not Be Afraid
    • Pray without Ceasing
    • Prepare the Way
    • Advent with the Angels
    • Take Up Your Cross
    • 15-Minute Stations of the Cross for Kids
  • Articles
  • Worksheets
  • Children’s Stories
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter

How do you respond to editor feedback?

By Jared Dees

First, look at feedback as an opportunity to learn and grow.

None of the comments or changes are meant to be personal attacks. Ignore the tone of brief comments. Don’t read into it. This person just read your entire book. Be grateful and recognize that editors are making the work and you better.

Second, tackle each change one at a time.

When you first get a manuscript back from your editor, the amount of work in terms of fixes and rewrites can be a little overwhelming. A good editor is going to send you back a Word document with challenging and thoughtful comments as well as a separate document with notes on areas that need to be improved. This is a great learning opportunity!

Here is the process I used last week to address my editor’s feedback and a recent manuscript:

  1. Fix grammatical errors. I asked my developmental editor to keep track changes on so I could review the grammatical changes. This was a great learning experience and I picked up on a number of bad habits and common errors in my writing. Doing this step first also gave me the chance to scan the comments that would require more thoughtful rewriting.
  2. Address each individual comment in the margins. I fixed some of these as I went through the grammar changes, but since these comments required more thought, I batched them together as one task. Sometimes this meant adding a few sentences or changing the wording of what I had written. Sometimes deleting a sentence or two fixed the problem.
  3. Finally, I went through and addressed the larger questions and issues that she wrote about to me in a separate document. This included universal changes of language, tone, tense, point of view, etc. This part took the longest, but it made the book so much better after these issues were addressed.

February 2, 2018 Filed Under: Author Tips, On Writing

About Jared Dees

Jared Dees is passionate about sharing practical resources to teach faith. He is best known for his website The Religion Teacher and is the author of many books including 31 Days to Becoming a Better Religious Educator, To Heal, Proclaim, and Teach, Praying the Angelus, Christ in the Classroom, and Beatitales: 80 Fables about the Beatitudes for Children.

Previous Post: « How I Accidentally Got into the Best Shape of My Life
Next Post: Long-term Oriented Thinking about Projects »

Primary Sidebar

Jared Dees

Author, Speaker, Teacher

📬 Tools to Teach Faith 📬

I send many weekly email newsletters every week with tools to pass on faith:

👨‍🏫 The Religion Teacher’s Sunday Planner 👨‍🏫

Lessons, activities, videos, and worksheets for religious educators.

Get teaching resources here >

📖 God’s Word Wednesday 📖

Bible stories for kids.

Get Bible stories for kids here >

🏰 Formative Fiction Friday 🏰

Short stories to help kids find confidence, character, and a relationship with Christ.

Get stories for kids here >

Jared’s Newest Books

  
    
 
 
   
 
 

Jared’s Popular Website for Religious Educators

Search the Site:

Footer

Connect with Jared Dees

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Jared Dees is passionate about sharing practical resources to teach faith. He is best known for his website The Religion Teacher and is the author of many books including 31 Days to Becoming a Better Religious Educator, To Heal, Proclaim, and Teach, Praying the Angelus, Christ in the Classroom, and Beatitales: 80 Fables about the Beatitudes for Children. See all of Jared's Books →

Stories for Children

Copyright © 2023 · Jared Dees